Inquirer Homepage Contact RSS Feed

Tuesday, September 05, 2006

The venomous debate this year over the Israel Lobby's influence over American foreign policy has all the makings of good old democratic dialogue: research, reasoning, lofty ideas, religious fervor, and plenty of irrelevant ad hominem vilification.

Israel Lobby War of Words: A Bibliography

Firestorm_1 The venomous debate this year over the Israel Lobby's influence over American foreign policy has all the makings of good old democratic dialogue: research, reasoning, lofty ideas, religious fervor, and plenty of irrelevant ad hominem vilification. What follows is a list of the major publications in the debate, for your reading pleasure.

Stephen Walt and John Mearsheimer originally wrote a piece on the power of the Israel Lobby for the Atlantic Monthly, but the magazine rejected it, and so began the firestorm.

<> Mearsheimer & Walt's original "Working Paper" posted on the Harvard website.

<> Similar piece, published in the London Review of Books.

<> Reader letters LRO published subsequently.

<> The New York Sun reports that Mearsheimer & Walt's paper has vindicated David Duke and the Palestinian Liberation Organization is distributing it in Washington.

<> Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz responds with, "Debunking the Newest - and Oldest - Jewish Conspiracy."

<> The New York Sun takes its reporting further, with headline: "Harvard's Paper on Israel Drew From Neo-Nazi Sites."

<> Michael Massing follows up with an in-depth, heavily-researched analysis of the situation in the New York Review of Books, and more importantly, an accounting of the power of the AIPAC in Washington.

<> Tony Judt, "A Lobby, Not a Conspiracy," in the New York Times.

<> Eliot Cohen, "Yes, It's Anti-Semitic," in the Washington Post.

<> Christopher Hitchens at Slate, "Overstating Jewish Power."

<> Even Noam Chomsky gets in on the action, "The Israel Lobby?"

(Image from flickr.)

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451669d69e200d8356892fa69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Israel Lobby War of Words: A Bibliography:

Comments

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In.